Why Your Lawyer’s First Questions Matter 
Being arrested for a DUI is a stressful experience, and your future can seem uncertain. The penalties for DUI offenses are severe, especially if you have prior convictions or if there are aggravating circumstances in your case. At Best and Brock, we understand how crucial it is for clients to understand the legal process. Your lawyer’s role is not just to represent you in court but also to help you navigate the complexities of the criminal justice system, and the first questions they ask can set the stage for your defense.
The first meeting with your DUI lawyer is your opportunity to discuss the specifics of your case. These early conversations often center around the events of the arrest, the circumstances surrounding it, and the strength of the evidence against you. In particular, your answers to certain key questions help your lawyer identify any potential weaknesses in the prosecution’s case, uncover possible defenses, and determine how to approach the trial.
A DUI lawyer does more than just review the facts—they evaluate every aspect of the arrest, from the legality of the traffic stop to the handling of the breathalyzer test. This is why those first questions are critical. But why do they focus on the details of your arrest? What exactly are they looking for, and how can this affect your case?
The First Questions Your Lawyer Will Ask
- “What happened during the traffic stop?” This question is designed to gather basic facts about how the arrest unfolded. Your lawyer wants to know whether the officer had probable cause for pulling you over in the first place. DUI arrests often hinge on the legality of the stop. If the police officer stopped you without a valid reason or if your rights were violated during the stop, it could lead to the dismissal of evidence or even the entire case. Understanding the details of the traffic stop can help your lawyer spot any procedural errors. For example, if the officer didn’t have a legitimate reason for stopping you—perhaps you weren’t speeding or swerving—it could be grounds for a motion to suppress evidence. In cases where the officer failed to adhere to proper protocols, it may significantly weaken the case against you.
- “Were you asked to perform field sobriety tests?” Field sobriety tests (FSTs) are often used as evidence in DUI cases. These tests measure your coordination, balance, and ability to follow instructions. However, they are not infallible. Factors like medical conditions, the environment (such as poor lighting or uneven pavement), or even nerves can affect your performance on these tests. Your lawyer needs to know if the tests were conducted fairly and if they were appropriately administered. If the officer didn’t follow proper procedures, or if you failed due to factors unrelated to your sobriety, your lawyer can use this information to challenge the validity of the test results. Your lawyer might also inquire about the number of tests given and the instructions provided—anything that could demonstrate that the tests were unfair or improperly conducted.
- “Did you submit to a breathalyzer or blood test?” Breathalyzer and blood tests are often central to DUI cases, as they provide a quantitative measure of your blood alcohol content (BAC). The reliability of these tests can be questioned, particularly if there were issues with how the test was administered. Breathalyzer machines must be properly calibrated, and blood tests must be handled according to strict protocols. Your lawyer will want to know whether you consented to a breathalyzer or blood test and whether the results are valid. Sometimes, tests can be challenged based on improper handling or inaccurate readings. In addition, your lawyer may ask whether the test was administered within the legally required time frame after the arrest, as delays can sometimes affect the results.
- “Have you been arrested for DUI before?” If this is your first offense, the penalties will generally be less severe than if you have prior DUI convictions. However, repeat offenders face enhanced penalties, including longer license suspensions, steeper fines, and the possibility of jail time. Your lawyer will ask this question to understand the potential consequences you may face, depending on your criminal history. This question is crucial because repeat offenders have fewer options for a favorable resolution of their case. In such cases, your lawyer may explore plea deals or other strategies to minimize the damage to your future. Having a previous conviction for DUI can also affect the defenses available to you.
- “Do you recall anything unusual during the arrest?” This question gives you the chance to mention any inconsistencies or unusual circumstances that may have affected the legality of the arrest. Were you read your rights? Was the officer polite, or were they aggressive or discriminatory? Did they properly inform you of your right to refuse a breathalyzer test? Even small discrepancies in the way the arrest was handled can have a significant impact on your case. By asking this question, your lawyer is looking for anything that could help in your defense, such as improper conduct by the officer, errors in procedure, or issues with the timing of tests. This could also help your lawyer identify any possible avenues for reducing the charges or negotiating a plea.
Garth Best was extremely helpful in my case. He explored and explained everything to me clearly and never stopped checking out every option. I am absolutely grateful I chose him as my attorney. Best and Brock are a great choice for representation. Thanks again.
- Jeremy Forgey
Matt Brock did an outstanding job with my case. Very thorough and knowledgeable attorney, highly recommended. Its very obvious through my interactions with him that he has the experience and knowledge to win in court. I will not go anywhere else. Great job, much appreciated.
- Chris Griffin
What Do These Questions Reveal About Your Case?
The first questions a DUI lawyer asks aren’t just for gathering facts—they help the lawyer assess the strength of the case and the best way to approach the defense. If your answers suggest that the arrest was conducted improperly, that the tests were not administered correctly, or that the evidence against you is weak, your lawyer may decide to fight the charges in court. Even if the evidence is strong, your lawyer may be able to negotiate a plea deal. For example, if this is your first offense, your lawyer might be able to reduce the charge to a lesser offense, such as reckless driving, which carries fewer consequences than a DUI conviction. In addition to challenging the evidence, these questions allow your lawyer to determine the overall strategy for your defense. Your lawyer will decide whether to challenge the breathalyzer results, question the arrest procedure, or argue that the officer lacked probable cause. They might also consider alternative strategies, such as seeking a reduced sentence or enrollment in alcohol education programs, especially if this is your first offense.Related Videos
Penalties for a DUI Conviction
Cost of a DUI Lawyer